The Short Review

shining the spotlight on short story collections

Edge Hill Prize shortlist

The five short story collections on the shortlist for the £5000 Edge Hill Prize for the Short Story have just been unveiled:

  • Chris Beckett, The Turing Test, Elastic Press
  • Gerard Donovan, Country of the Grand, Faber (reviewed as Young Irelanders, the US title)
  • Anne Enright, Yesterday’s Weather, Random House
  • Shena Mackay, The Atmospheric Railway, Random House
  • Ali Smith, The First Person and Other Stories, Hamish Hamilton (review coming soon!)

Congratulations to all the shortlisted, an interesting list pitting four rather big names in literary fiction, all of whom are either MAN Booker Prize winners or nominees, and published by large publishers, against Chris Beckett – a small-press-published author of a collection whose stories, says the Edge Hill website, “feature, among other things, robots, alien planets, genetic manipulation and virtual reality, but their centre focuses on individuals rather than technology, and they deal with love and loneliness, authenticity and illusion, and what it really means to be human”. Elastic Press must be hopping up and down with glee!

Last year’s shortlist did seem to me rather more eclectic:

  • Tiny Deaths by Robert Shearman (Comma Press)
  • The Separate Heart by Simon Robson (Jonathan Cape)
  • Walk the Blue Fields by Claire Keegan (Faber and Faber)
  • The People on Privilege Hill by Jane Gardam (Chatto and Windus)
  • Old Devil Moon by Christopher Fowler (Serpent’s Tail)

Tiny Deaths is the first collection by Doctor Who writer Shearman, The Separate Heart is Simon Robson’s debut collection, Walk the Blue Fields is Clare Keegan’s second collection, Jane Gardam is the author of too many novels and short story collections to mention, and Old Devil Moon is Christopher Fowler’s 10th collection of dark short fiction.

It is wonderful that there is a prize for short story collections, don’t get me wrong, but we have reviewed so many excellent small-press published collections and debut collections by exciting and talented new writers over the past year, it is a shame that they didn’t get a stronger showing on the shortlist this year.

I understand that picking 5 is an impossible task, perhaps the Edge Hill prize organisers could take a leaf out of the Frank O’Connor International Award for the Short Story‘s book: they publish a longlist that includes every book entered that fits the eligibility criteria. This year’s longlist will be announced next week, and if last year is anything to go by it will include 50 or so short story collections (among them, in the interests of full disclosure, my own collection, The White Road and Other Stories). This will be whittled down to 5 books for the shortlist – but the longlist was published last year in the Guardian and all the books received a much-needed boost.

All of us aim to spread the word about great short stories, and the Frank O’Connor Award longlist accomplishes this simply and effectively – we can’t all be winners, but just the fact of getting published is an achievement worth celebrating! Good luck to all!

8 comments on “Edge Hill Prize shortlist

  1. bevjackson
    May 7, 2009

    Good insights, Tania, and I agree, it must be very difficult. (and no accounting for taste, either) Good luck to you on hitting the short list too!!


  2. Alan Beard
    May 7, 2009

    Hi Tania,congrats on your flash making the Wigleaf top 50. I agree about small press collections getting a mention at least in longlists. However I’m glad Gerard Donovan is on the list – I won the book from the Short Review last year and was delighted with it. One story in particular was forty types of fab.(Harry Dietz).Anyway, good luck on future flashes and stories.Alan


    May 7, 2009

    I agree T. Any exposure the short sotry can get is great!


  4. Tania Hershman
    May 7, 2009

    Bev,it’s just the longlist and all eligible books are on it, but it’s very nice all the same!Alan, thanks so much, it was quite a shock! So glad you enjoyed the Gerard Donovan book, I bet winning it made that even sweeter. I must get myself a copy. WRW – absolutely. Good for the F o’C!


  5. Tim Jones
    May 8, 2009

    I find myself wanting to vote for the Chris Beckett book, sight unseen (if I had the power to do so) – would that be so very wrong of me?


  6. Tania Hershman
    May 8, 2009

    Ha! I have that urge too… I think it would be wrong, yes. Naughty! That’s just as bad as non-anonymous judging.


  7. Alan
    May 11, 2009

    Tania, the wigleaf thing was well deserved.


  8. Tania Hershman
    May 11, 2009

    Thanks, Alan!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on May 7, 2009 by in awards, competitions, longlist, short fiction, short stories, shortlist.
%d bloggers like this: